Written by TotalArsenal
In the first TotalArsenal post for ‘ArsenalArsenal’, I focussed on the position of our manager and came to the conclusion we should let him complete his mission to turn us once again into the top team we all crave for. In the second TotalArsenal post, I focussed on the positives within our, young and quickly developing squad and why there is plenty to be upbeat about for next season. In this post, I will make a comparison between us and our competitors by focussing on the key areas of: squad, manager, transfer potential, and previous success/confidence levels. The comparisons below are of course not the pinnacle of scientific analysis, but should help to start a good debate about where we are compared to our competitors at this ‘early stage of the new season’.
Manchester United
Squad: New goalkeeper required and doubts about Ferdinand and RB position. Centre of midfield is also an issue. They have strong attacking options with some dependency on (injury prone) Rooney as the ‘main man’.
Manager: Safe pair of hands (health permitting), with success both in the past and most recently.
Transfer Potential (available cash & attractiveness): Medium to good. Decent funds are available and they have a medium to high attractiveness to foreign and British players.
Success in last season & confidence levels: Won the PL, but doubts about away form (only won 5 games). They have a fantastic home form which is likely to continue next season. Confidence will be medium to high.
Candidate to win PL title? Strong candidate to win title again, but squad needs further investment and changes will have to be successfully embedded. Away form needs to improve drastically.
Chelsea
Squad: Mature squad with strength in all areas, with the exception of creative central midfielders. Are former key players past their best (Terry, Lampard, Drogba, Essien)? Might need rejuvenating, which would take time to embed.
Manager: To be recruited. He will start with a clean sheet, but will need time to settle in, for which he will not have very long.
Transfer Potential (available cash & attractiveness): Good to great, depending on Abramovic’s desperation to splash the cash once again. Not all top players consider Chelsea as a ‘top club’.
Success in last season & confidence levels: Won nothing, but became 2nd in PL. Confidence is relatively low and new manager will have to do a big job in making the players believe they can win the major trophies.
Candidate to win PL title? Medium to strong candidate to win the title. Even when some top players are added to team, it might take time for the new manager to integrate them all into the team, and put his stamp on it.
Manchester City
Squad: Large squad with potential, but not yet top class. Likely to lose their talisman Tevez who will be difficult to replace. Strength in depth though with a good average age.
Manager: Made enough progress this season to be given another year. Jury’s still out though. They have had some decent recent successes to build on further, but Mancini will feel the pressure this season more than ever.
Transfer Potential (available cash & attractiveness): Medium to good. Endless funds, but struggling to attract top-top quality players, but qualification for CL might change this.
Success in last season & confidence levels: Enough success (3rd place & FA cup) to build up their confidence for next season. The next step for MC will be a lot bigger though, and expectations will be a lot higher next season.
Candidate to win PL title? Medium candidate. They will buy more players but has Mancini what it takes to make the final step up? Expectations will be high and the pressure will be more intense then ever for them.
Liverpool
Squad: Good squad with a possible need for more strength in depth (especially in defence).
Manager: Can he do it again after such a long absence in top management? Made great impact on team this season, but there was relatively little pressure on him.
Transfer Potential (available cash & attractiveness): Medium. New American owners are not regarded as big-big spenders. Liverpool has no CL so might find it difficult to attract top-top talent.
Success in last season & confidence levels: Won nothing, but had a good recovery and beat comprehensively both Chelsea and MU in recent months. Expectations will be high in Merseyside and they have it all to prove.
Candidate to win PL title? Low to medium candidate. Expectations will be high, but will they attract the right calibre of players, and has Dalglish what it takes to guide them to the title?
Tottenham Hotspur
Squad: Medium to good squad with some strength in depth, although question remains whether they have enough quality throughout the key areas.
Manager: Seems to over-deliver at small stage but under-deliver at the big one. The team has stagnated this year under his leadership (despite some success in CL).
Transfer Potential (available cash & attractiveness): Low to medium. No CL will make it difficult to attract top players and funds are not at top-level either.
Success in last season & confidence levels: Won nothing but did relatively well in CL on which they can build confidence.
Candidate to win PL title? Low. Seem a long way off to come anywhere near winning the PL and do not seem to have the funds to attract new quality players.
Arsenal
Squad: Good squad now that TV and Rambo have returned. We need to invest though in our strength of depth and to add some experience, both in defence and in attack (winger).
Manager: Safe pair of hands with successes in the past but not recently. Has been rebuilding the squad but team is struggling to make the final step to success under his leadership. Wenger will be under a lot of pressure again next season.
Transfer Potential (available cash & attractiveness): Medium. Funds should be better than previous seasons and Arsenal remain an attractive team for good-to-top players.
Success in last season & confidence levels: Won nothing and then there were the disastrous final month of last season, which have harmed confidence levels of the team. Wenger and coaching staff have a big job to do in preparing us mentally for next season.
Candidate to win PL title? Medium to strong. The basics are in place with a talented squad that keeps improving. The squad is expected to be strengthened with a few new additions, but expectations will be high and confidence will remain brittle until we win something.
I have translated the above comparisons into a points table (1-5: 1 = low and 5 = high):
| Team | Squad | Manager | Transfer Potential | Success & confidence | Total |
| MU | 4 | 5 | 3 | 4 | 16 |
| Chelsea | 4 | 2 | 4 | 2 | 12 |
| MC | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 12 |
| Liverpool | 3 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 09 |
| Spurs | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 09 |
| Arsenal | 4 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 13 |
To me the table shows we are in a decent-to-good position compared to our competitors at this stage of the season. Once again, MU will be our strongest competitor, but Chelsea and MC are equal threats. If we can get a few quality additions to the team, and Wenger and his staff can rebuild our brittle confidence levels again over the summer, we will be competing again for next year’s PL title.
TotalArsenal, 30 May 2011.
Posted by peachesgÖÖner
Arsenal News 24/7
